The Motley Fool Rule Breakers Review

Motley Fool's Rule Breakers is a stock picking service that focuses on identifying and recommending stocks with ultra-high growth potential. It was started in 2004 and has an unabashed and overtly stated goal to “beat the market.

Rule Breakers logo

Our Partner

Growth Stock Newsletter


  • Hyper growth-focused stock ideas 
  • Proven track record of profitable trades
  • Low yearly fees
  • 30-Day Money Back Guarantee
Overall Rating

B BBB Rating

Average review rating 3.7/5 on TrustPilot

Some of the links in this post are from our sponsors. We provide you with accurate, reliable information. Read our Advertising Disclosure.

Pros & Cons

I take Rule Breakers at face value; I think you are getting what you pay for. However, I would more specifically note some important “pros” and “cons” of the service that should definitely be considered. 


  • Impressive record of picking some real winners
  • Monthly growth stock picks
  • Buy and sell alerts
  • Pricing appears to be fairly straightforward


  • Not designed for short-term traders or day-traders
  • Customer service is available on a very limited basis

This review will examine the details of what is offered by this service, the cost, and whether or not I think it is worth subscribing to.

If I think it is worth your time and the financial outlay, I will say so plainly; conversely, if I think you would be better off going with another service or doing your own research and investing your money accordingly, I will be equally candid as well.

Let's get started and see if Motley Fool Rule Breakers is worth trying and the results you might expect to get from some Rule Breakers portfolio additions.

Rule Breakers Icon

Quick Summary

Service: Growth Stock Ideas

Cost: $99/year

Promotion: 30 Day Money Back Guarantee

About Motley Fool Rule Breakers

Motley Fool Rule Breakers” is an online site and electronic newsletter which provides subscribers with a number of stock picks as identified by Motley Fool co-founder David Gardner and his staff. 

It was started in 2004.

Who Are David & Tom Gardner?

David Gardner and Tom Gardner

David Gardner is the principal figure behind the Rule Breakers website and service, while his younger brother Tom Gardner and he both spearhead the “Stock Advisor” platform. 

They have been involved in stock-picking for some time and have co-authored numerous books on the subject. 

What's Included with the Service?

Most of the action on the Rule Breakers site takes place at regular intervals, namely on Thursdays.  This is when not only regular updates occur, but also when their “New Stock Recommendation” is revealed (every second and fourth Thursday of the month to be exact) and their “5 Best Buys Now” are published (on every third Thursday), for example. 

Subscribers can then act on the email itself and just the names of the stocks being touted, of they can go to the website to review the associated analytical data from which the picks were generated.

Each of these updates is accompanied by an email to subscribers notifying them of said updates and their attendant details.

This information includes various charts and the like, as well as discussion boards where fellow members can weigh in on what they think of the picks and what they are inclined to do.

The latter is, predictably enough, where one can find affirmation that reinforces one’s convictions to act, or, on the hand, opinions which might somewhat chasten their strongest inclinations. 

What is the Price?

The Rule Breakers service used to cost $199 per year, however, it now costs $99 per year (as of 2022). They also periodically float trial offers, some for as low as $19.

It's in-house rival service, Stock Advisor, also costs $19 per month or $99 for an entire year. Although the costs are the same, we consider Rule Breakers to be the more robust and comprehensive of the two offerings.

However, does our opinion automatically equate to more success in the market for Rule Breakers vis-à-vis its sibling offering?

Well, it really depends on how you define “success”.

Motley Fool Rule Breakers Price

Motley Fool Rule Breakers vs. Motley Fool Stock Advisor

Motley Fool Rule Breakers Review
Stock Advisor review

One eminently fair way to gauge the success (and therefore the value) of Rule Breakers is to compare it to the afore-mentioned Motley Fool Stock Advisor.

Stock Advisor is the home of 'Foundation Stocks' (previously known as 'Starter Stocks' - what the team believes to be long-term good bets).

While research seems to indicate that Rule Breakers focuses on identifying individual high-growth stocks that have “beat the market”, Motley Fool's Stock Advisor has been more consistent in terms of picking “winners” across the breadth of their recommended portfolio.

Stated a bit differently, Rule Breakers has indeed, over time, picked a number of run-away winners, however, because they seemingly always go for the 500-ft home run when maybe a bases-clearing double would do, they also strike out far more often than their cheaper competitor.

Rule Breakers Performance
Stock Advisor Performance

When it comes to Rule Breakers picks, they swings for the fences, game situation and score be damned, while their competitor (Stock Advisor) is content with more of a “station-to-station” type approach, to further utilize the baseball analogy.

Either strategy can win you the game, but the question is, again, what do you consider a “win”?  High risk and potential high reward, or lower risk and possible lower reward?

While in the midst of what is, generally speaking, your prime income-earning age range (about 30 to 50 years old), retirement may seem so far off as to be fairly inconsequential.

That said, you may be more inclined to “go big” as opposed to adhering to a more conservative approach. Rule Breakers seems to get that, and as such, you represent their primary subscriber pool.

They seem to realize that for you success is defined by big gains, even if extreme volatility and more than a fair share of heartburn is involved; truthfully, you should indeed expect a sizable bit of heartburn to accompany your “grand-slams-only” portfolio.

Customer Testimonials & Results

In terms of testimonials, based on what I have found, opinion seems to be fairly evenly split; some Twitter, Reddit, and other online commentary/rants swear by the Rule Breakers service’s picks, while others have decried it as a “scam” and a waste of money. 

Some of the more contemplative opinions, which I, for the record, think may be most accurate, make the point that you are getting pretty much what you pay for: if you choose to subscribe to Rule Breakers you are in effect ceding your investment decisions to other fallible human beings who may or may not find you the extreme success that you may hoping for.

Motley Fool Stock Advisor Reviews

Most credible reviews indicate a performance level of twice the “S&P 500” for their picks, however hyper-volatile stocks such as Tesla had helped to significantly boost those numbers.

If you have held onto Tesla how does your portfolio look now? “Buy-and-hold” has noteworthy limitations. 

Who is Rule Breakers Best For?

In a bit of a “Goldilocks” confluence of interests, the Rule Breakers subscription target market (to their credit) is exactly who it seems best suited for, namely those who would rather engage in a markedly passive investment approach.

These investors are in the car/market and therefore very much at risk, however, they are decidedly not at the wheel. 

Should I Buy Motley Fool Rule Breakers?

If you are investor that is looking for long-term growth stock market ideas, then I would highly recommend subscribing to Motley Fool Rule Breakers, especially at the low cost of only $99 per year.

Tom & David's track record of picking profitable long-term growth stocks, coupled with their extensive research they do for each pick, makes this a no-brainer in my opinion.

Just remember that with any investment that you decide to act on, make sure that you do your own research and due diligence.

I would recommend at least giving the service a try and if you aren't satisfied, then they do offer a 30-Day money back guarantee, which is always good.

Motley Fool Rule Breakers

Motley Fool Rule Breakers is a stock picking service that focuses on identifying and recommending stocks with ultra-high growth potential. It was started in 2004 and has an unabashed and overtly stated goal to “beat the market.

Rule Breakers Icon
  • Editor Rating
  • Rated 4.5 stars
  • 80%

  • Motley Fool Rule Breakers
  • Reviewed by:
  • Published on:
  • Last modified: July 25, 2022

You may also like